Country reports describing serious violence may be important evidence, but they must be connected to the individual’s likely risk of torture. In Matter of K-Y-V-R-, 30 I&N Dec. 203 (BIA 2026), the Board of Immigration Appeals vacated an immigration judge’s grant of withholding of removal under the Convention Against Torture (CAT), finding that the predictions of future torture and inability to relocate were speculative and insufficiently supported by the record.
The Board noted that the respondent had relatives in El Salvador, including uncles who worked as police officers, and that he was now an able-bodied adult. It found insufficient evidence that he could not relocate elsewhere in El Salvador and obtain employment.
The Board decided the case on September 10, 2026. The Attorney General designated it as precedent on October 27. The decision underscores the need to explain why documented country conditions place this particular person at risk.
What Does CAT Protection Require?
For CAT protection, an applicant must establish that it is more likely than not that they would be tortured if removed. The legal standard also requires the necessary connection to a public official, such as torture by an official or with an official’s consent or acquiescence, which can include willful blindness.
Evidence of danger is therefore part of a more specific legal inquiry. Counsel must assess the nature and likelihood of the anticipated harm, the individual’s circumstances, relevant country conditions, relocation evidence, and the government’s role.
Why Did the Board Reverse This CAT Grant?
The respondent described gang threats and recruitment efforts in El Salvador before he left in 2015 at age 17. The Board found insufficient evidence that the gang remained interested in him years later. The record did not establish that gang members had continued searching for him or questioning his family about him after his departure.
The Board also found the internal-relocation analysis unsupported. It questioned assumptions about education, employment, and a lack of family support, noting record evidence about relatives and the fact that the respondent was now an adult.
Because the Board rejected the finding that future torture was more likely than not, it did not reach the separate question of government acquiescence. The appeal resulted in reversal of CAT protection and an order of removal.
Connect the General Evidence to the Personal Record
| Evidence issue | Questions to explore with counsel |
|---|---|
| Continuing interest in the applicant | Are there recent threats, inquiries, messages, or other reliable facts showing why the feared actors would target this person now? |
| Country conditions | How do reports, research, or expert evidence relate to the applicant’s location, history, identity, or specific circumstances? |
| Internal relocation | What record evidence supports or undermines the possibility of avoiding the feared torture elsewhere in the country? Address assumptions about family and practical circumstances. |
| Government involvement or acquiescence | What evidence supports the required public-official connection? This remains a separate element even though the Board did not decide it in K-Y-V-R-. |
What the Decision Does Not Say
The decision does not make country reports irrelevant. It also does not create a universal requirement that every applicant obtain a new direct threat or first attempt relocation. The inquiry depends on the full record and the applicable legal standard.
A report can help explain the reach of a particular group, the treatment of people with relevant characteristics, or the government’s response. Its usefulness grows when the case explains the connection rather than assuming that widespread violence proves every individual faces probable torture.
Families can help by preserving relevant messages and records and giving counsel a complete timeline. Explain what is known, what is uncertain, and why some evidence may be unavailable. A careful analysis must also confront evidence that appears inconsistent with the claimed risk.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are country-condition reports enough to win CAT protection?
Not necessarily. Generalized violence evidence must be evaluated with the individual record to determine whether torture is more likely than not and whether the required government connection exists.
Did Matter of K-Y-V-R- decide government acquiescence?
No. The Board did not reach that separate issue because its finding on the likelihood of future torture resolved the CAT claim.
Does this case require everyone to try relocating first?
Under 8 C.F.R. § 1208.16(c)(3), evidence concerning whether an applicant could relocate to an area where torture is unlikely is one factor in assessing the probability of future torture. The regulation does not impose a categorical requirement that applicants first attempt relocation.
Review Your Options With an Immigration Attorney
Wilner & O’Reilly helps individuals and families evaluate removal defense and immigration options. Contact our team to discuss your case and the records an attorney should review.
Official Sources
- Matter of K-Y-V-R-, 30 I&N Dec. 203 (BIA 2026) — full BIA decision
- EOIR: Volume 30 precedent decisions
Prepared November 3, 2026. This article provides general information, not legal advice. The applicable statute, procedural history, evidence, and controlling federal circuit law can affect an individual case.


Comments are closed.